Sticks and Stones: Were Tiger's words worse than Tilghman's?

Print E-mail

Tiger Woods is the man.

He could beat God in match-play and probably wouldn't need every hole to do so. If he happens to hit a wayward drive into a water hazard, have no fear he'll simply walk on water to retrieve his ball. Well you get the point; the man is worshiped and rightfully so. He is the single most spectacular athlete of our time and perhaps the most captivating of all-time.

But does Tiger deserve a free pass on a blatantly offensive remark he made at the recently concluded CA Championship at Doral as much as Kelly Tilghman deserved to be drug through the mud for a blatantly offensive mark she made about him.

Or better yet, would you rather be lynched in a back alley or have your f****** neck broken?

I think if anything, the two remarks deserve equal criticism.

During the PGA TOUR's season opening tournament, Tilghman made a phenomenally stupid mistake when she countered her partner Nick Faldo's banter about what should be done to stop Tiger with "lynch him in a back alley."

Sure it was a horrendous choice of words and a terribly regretful attempt at humor, but I'm not sure if after careful inspection it was a more egregious error in judgment.
 
Tiger's camp quickly came to Tilghman's defense, and released a statement that read: "Tiger and Kelly are friends, and Tiger has a great deal of respect for Kelly. Regardless of the choice of words use, we know unequivocally that there was no ill intent in her comments. This story is a non-issue in our eyes. Case closed."

Despite the denials of Tigers displeasure, Tilghman was suspended from her on-air position for two weeks and chastised in the mainstream media by the likes of blowhard Al Sharpton.

But in an interesting twist to that story, Tiger had his own potty mouth moment this past Sunday and I don't know if we can yet ascertain whether it was "unequivocally" not of a malicious nature.

Like it has happened many a time before, an either unaware or unskilled photographer clicked in Tiger's backswing which resulted in a verbal barrage from the world's No. 1 player.

Tiger's tirade is reported to have included: "The next time a photographer shoots a f****** picture on my backswing, I'm going to break his f****** neck."

Wow.

The whole argument from Tiger fans and supporters, who in turn displayed support for Tilghman earlier in the year, uttered things like, "People need to lighten up. If this isn't bothering Tiger, then who the heck cares."

Well do we really think this not in the least bit bothered by what transpired. I'm almost certain given the chance the 'backswing-clicker' would have been apologetic. I would imagine the comments at least embarrassed and degraded him. He probably went home and told his wife, "Hey honey, Tiger Woods threatened to end my life today."

Tiger, who really does live like he owns a printing press stamping out his own currency, should gain a bit of perspective. So should some members of the media.

An L.A. Times columnist launched into a lecture directed at photographers and the PGA TOUR saying, "The Tour needs to have mandatory meetings for all photographers before each tournament. Photographers need to know when they can and can't shoot. I'm willing to bet the latest guy to break the rules had no idea he couldn't shoot in Tiger's backswing."

This is all correct. The photographers did have a hand in contributing to this incident but let's not use it to excuse what Tiger said.

The Times writer concluded, "Let's hope the PGA TOUR will handled photographers before Tiger takes his first swing."

Let's hope the Tour does take action before Tiger goes all Latrell Sprewell on one of these guys. I mean how would Tiger like walking around in Britney Spears' shoes for a day? There wouldn't be enough of those ugly, cumbersome neck braces for everyone.

All joking aside, Tiger was in the heat of the battle and he said a stupid thing but what's worse and almost unexplainable is his lack of an apology when given the chance.

"It's been frustrating because that's what's been happening lately," Woods told ESPN's First Take Wednesday morning. "It's one of the things that comes with playing in the last group, one of the distractions we have to deal with."

And when asked specifically about the language used he said, "You have no idea what's been said on the golf course all the time, in any sport really. It was the heat of the moment. That one shot took the momentum I had built on No. 8."

Unequivocally unapologetic.

All he had so say was a simple "I'm sorry for how I reacted. That was very unbecoming of a PGA TOUR golfer, especially someone in my position as a revered figure all over the world."

Tilgham had to apologize and so should Tiger.

Comments
Add NewSearch
John Woods - You knew how he was long befor     | 167.239.216.199 | 2008-04-02 11:39:16
I lost all respect for Tiger a long time ago when he won the Masters. Fuzzy Zoeller made a commect about the dinner Tiger got to pick for the players and Tiger never let it slide. Everyone knew that Fuzzy's comment was made in jest but Tiger never let it go when asked about it in an interview. He's just as bad if not worst because of his visibility in the public's eye. If he wants to be held on a higher perch then he has to be held accountable for what he says while he's up there.
Anonymous   | 75.26.32.86 | 2008-04-02 12:51:28
I would like to see anyone else stand up to the scrutiny Tiger Woods is put under every single day. With autographs, photos, interviews, massive crowds following him everywhere and personal appearances he still manages to present himself as a respectable athlete. The kind of athlete I would want my son to look up to. He treats people as he would want to be treated, with respect. The one time he
Don Hurst   | 65.188.161.80 | 2008-04-02 13:40:31
Yes, Tiger should apologize. And Tiger should really, really work on his bad language when he, sometimes, hits a bad shot. A lot of youngsters and other fans are watching him every minute and his outbursts, though usually short and not for the same reasons as this latest, are not becoming of a star as he is. They are not becoming of anyone on television and he should be held accountable. I'm a big Tiger fan but I will accept any kind of reprimand given him for those obscene outbursts. I don't care if it's a two stroke penalty, calling his mother, not getting to play in the next major tournament, etc. He needs to be made to stop![color=black][/ color][color=black][
/ color][size=medium][
/size]
Chuck Collet - Retired Greens Supervisor   | 64.59.144.22 | 2008-04-02 13:44:14
For years I've often used the term, "If you do that again I'm gonna have to kill ya..., and Sometimes.. I might really have liked to.. So Tiger Woods makes an off colour remark after being distracted on his backswing, so what!! Is the problem what he said, or the double use of the "F" word. if it's the "Word", I would suggest everyone just drop the subject. What we are watching when we watch professional golf, or any other sport for that matter, we will have to get used to hearing the word. This as"I" see it, the word is "common usage". I'm willing to bet there isn't a person who has ever played 18 holes of golf in a foursome, (even if it was with one of the Presidents of the United States), and not heard it uttered in frustration over a screwed up shot. Beside that, it may be time to grow up and realize it is "JUST A WORD". yea, you heard me, it's "JUST A WORD". It isn't a challenge to world peace, and even if it offends some folks, they should remember that there are likely many things they say that offend others on many levels.. So come on Guys and Girls, GIVE IT A G.D. REST....Chuck Collet, Pitt Meadows, British Columbia
Dan   | 98.215.158.136 | 2008-04-02 14:29:31
[color=black][/ color][size=medium][
/size]
Tiger needs to apologize without a doubt. Excuse me, but blessing his outbursts or just blowing them off, is a greater indicator of our society as a whole. No right, no wrong, everything is relative. Pathetic mindsets are what are beginning now to invade what was once a game of honor. Tiger is somehow thought to be above any criticism or any rebuff for his actions. On the contrary, anyone with the platform he has for setting an example for young and old alike, should rethink why he does what he does. His chosen vocation, comes with some of these incidents. As a professional he should be held to a higher standard. No matter what people want to think, this game called golf, is just that. It's a "game"!! Yes he plays for millions, but he has multimillions and still his demeanor tells be he's not happy inside. This is not the first time this has happened either. Almost weekly I hear him cussing and swearing, or smashing his clubs into the ground, or throwing them down to the ground in disgust when things don't go perfect for him. I remember him saying once, that his father told when he was young, that if he ever threw his clubs, that would be the last time he played. Perhaps he should recall his fathers words of wisdom, and incorporate some restraint in his antics as well.
John - right!!!!!!!!!     | 167.239.207.25 | 2008-04-03 07:03:19
wrong
Brandon Underwood - Onlilne Editor   | 65.244.134.242 | 2008-04-02 14:29:37
Many of the points made are on target but like my article, they beg some more important questions. While the language used by Tiger may be offensive to some, it doesn't even register as out of the ordinary for many of us. Right?

I think the level of scrutiny surrounding Tiger will indeed put his poor choices in the spotlight because as a nation we love controversy.

But as has become customary, one stupid comment sometimes follows a celebrity for quite some time. I think a simple apology would have done a lot to put this incident to bed. I watched the clip of Tiger reacting to questions about this and he almost seemed jovial and proud of himself, which I found odd.

But I do agree, even in Tiger's case, it's impossible to be perfect. However, this is true for Kelly Tilgham. Many, if not all of us, say regrettable things on a day to day basis. Mistakes and misstatements, even by billionaire golfers will happen.

The article was more of a commentary on our race to judgment stemming from the earlier incident, rather than an indictment of Tiger.
CW - Everyone needs to lighten up   | 76.101.158.42 | 2008-04-02 16:28:29
Wow! How bad can it be, when we think this is news? And, for anyone who's ever been in the throes of competition, let's all be a little more understanding. You can't tell me that shooting a photo in the middle of Tiger's backswing was a mistake. Everyone knows that is a huge no-no. And, the tour officials should be ashamed for not doing a better job of policing it.
It doesn't excuse the barrage of expletives from Tiger, but, what would you do if it blew your chance for a win that would put you in the record books again?
Unless you've walked in his shoes, you should not judge.
Adam Paul - not even close to the same   | 66.149.92.140 | 2008-04-16 08:21:07
There is no relationship between the two comments. In the public eye a superstar should not curse, agreed(reason #42 on why I should ot be a public speaker). In public, private, semi-private or semi- public nobody should use racial remarks. Should Tiger be repremanded maybe... but, his remarks should not be even closely graded with a lynching comment.

In this day and age nobody should blame a person for being upset after being discriminated against. And surely not lose respect for a person for them not liking being discriminated against. If you don't cuss good for you. If you don't make racially discriminating remarks a gold star.
ep - To slip or not?   | 207.250.78.1 | 2008-04-16 11:44:38
whether he slipped, and burped a cuss word, is not acceptable? Then religous leaders, can never or should never burp the same cuss words? Unless, they immediately, say: Forgive Me Father!
Larry Jacobson   | 98.193.40.205 | 2008-04-16 12:06:37
In this day of high tech, don't they have cameras that have no clicking sounds? Ban all cameras from courses that make clicking sounds and eliminate the problem. Any photographer caught taking a picture that interferes with a golfer's swing should be taken into the back alley and .....
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
 
Security Image
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.
 

ON OUR MIND - Golf blog

Two golf pioneers to be celebrated for their contributions to the game during PLAYERS Championship
Tuesday, 06 May 2008

This week one of the deepest fields in all of golf will vie for the richest prize offered in a golf tournament in the United States. They'll also be battling for critical position in the FedEx Cup...
Full Story

Five Miller Lites and some orange juice
Monday, 05 May 2008

John Daly is to golf what Mike Tyson is to boxing. Last week Tyson appeared in a piece by Jeremy Schapp on ESPN's relatively new news magazine show E:60 talking about his past and admitted that...
Full Story

Book Review: The Golfer's Guide to the Meaning of Life
Tuesday, 29 April 2008

Gary Player is recognized as one of the most successful golfers of all-time. He is a member of the exclusive club of men who have captured golf’s grand slam. Lapping the globe and becoming...
Full Story

More from Arizona Golf Blog
Advertisement
Advertisement

Golf Poll

Which course would you most like to play on an Arizona Golf Vacation?